
Chicago's All-Star winger Marco Pappa is one of the biggest bargains in the league. (Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)
The MLS Players Union released its updated list of salaries for every MLS player on Thursday, providing the first clear look at the earnings of newly-added stars like New York’s Thierry Henry and Rafael Márquez, who instantly became the league’s second- and third-highest-paid players. When I posted the link on my Twitter page, a lot of my non-U.S. readers were startled that so much detailed salary information was available, considering it’s unheard of in the world’s other leagues. This is sensitive information, after all, and you certainly don’t see most people (me included) publicizing their salaries for the world to see.
Why would the MLS Players Union release this information? Because the transparency helps the collective, allowing players on the lower end of the pay scale to negotiate higher salaries than they would otherwise. And in MLS the lower end of the scale, as we know, can be awfully low. Still, the minimum salary for a senior player has risen to $40,000, which is better than it used to be.
I fed the latest MLS salary numbers into my spreadsheet and came up with some useful stats. Keep in mind, the salaries below reflect a player’s guaranteed annual income over 12 months. Let’s dive in:
AVERAGE MLS SALARY: $173,491
MEDIAN MLS SALARY: $92,375 (Carlos Mendes, New York)
MINIMUM SALARY: $40,000 (90 of 411 players)
TOP 10 MLS SALARIES *
(* Does not include San Jose’s recent signing of Geovanni, which came after the Players Union salary survey was taken.)
1. David Beckham, Los Angeles: $6,500,000
2. Thierry Henry, New York: $5,600,000
3. Rafael Márquez, New York: $5,554,000
4. Landon Donovan, Los Angeles: $2,127,778
5. Juan Pablo Ángel, New York: $1,918,000
6. Nery Castillo, Chicago: $1,788,060
7. Julian de Guzman, Toronto: $1,717,546
8. Freddie Ljungberg, Chicago: $1,314,000
9. Mista, Toronto: $987,337
10. Branko Boskovič, D.C. United: $516,200
MLS SALARIES BY TEAM *
(* Does not include signings after August 12.)
Anyone who’s concerned about the growing separation between MLS’s large- and small-market teams will take pause in the team-by-team spending figures below. While 12 teams are clumped together, four teams (New York, Los Angeles, Chicago and Toronto) have distanced themselves from the rest of the league with their signings of so-called Designated Players, whose salaries are not governed by the salary cap. (Each team can now have up to three DPs.)
1. New York: $15,666,639
2. Los Angeles: $10,978,593
3. Chicago: $5,559,103
4. Toronto: $5,214,381
5. Seattle: $3,118,103
6. New England: $2,983,032
7. Dallas: $2,924,318
8. Kansas City: $2,905,107
9. Philadelphia: $2,886,399
10. D.C. United: $2,881,530
11. Columbus: $2,808,203
12. Colorado: $2,710,113
13. Salt Lake: $2,645,721
14. Houston: $2,565,875
15. San Jose: $2,518,590
16. Chivas USA: $2,477,548
MOST OVERPAID MLS PLAYERS
Considering MLS’s microscopic per-team salary cap (DPs excepted), it’s not surprising that there are far more underpaid players than overpaid players in the league. For my purposes, nobody earning under $100,000 could be considered overpaid, and in my Overpaid list I did not include rookies, Generation Adidas players, recently signed players (like Nery Castillo) or players who have missed a lot of time due to injuries. Injuries are part of the game, as David Beckham ($6.5 million) and Taylor Twellman ($459,500) would tell you. But there are a few players who would have to be considered overpaid:
Sunil Chhetri, Kansas City ($110,008)
(Indian national-teamer got plenty of attention but wasn’t good enough to play in a single MLS game before being loaned back to Indian team through January’s Asian Cup.)
Freddie Ljungberg, Chicago ($1,314,000)
(Swedish winger earned his salary last year but went south fast before being dumped by Seattle.)
Fred, Philadelphia ($282,000)
Brazilian has just 2 goals and 1 assist in 18 games.
Julian de Guzman, Toronto ($1,717,546)
Hasn’t played nearly as well as his Spanish-league pedigree would suggest.
Darío Sala, Dallas ($178,125)
Making way too much for an MLS keeper who lost his job.
Danny Allsopp, D.C. United ($217,500)
Aussie has scored only twice all season for woeful United.
Carl Robinson, New York ($315,000)
Hasn’t produced in either Toronto or New York.
Josh Wolff, Kansas City ($220,004)
Just 1 goal in 17 games.
MOST UNDERPAID MLS PLAYERS
Sebastian Le Toux, Philadelphia ($122,000)
(League MVP candidate has 9 goals and 9 assists.)
Tim Ream, New York ($40,000)
(U.S. national team prospect is solid on the ball for a central defender, paid far less than many other rookies.)
Marco Pappa, Chicago ($108,000)
(All-Star left winger, just 22, has 7 goals and 4 assists.)
Edson Buddle, Los Angeles ($188,448)
(League MVP favorite leads MLS with 13 goals.)
Guillermo Barros Schelotto, Columbus ($241,250)
(Ageless Argentine wonder—5 goals and 7 assists—is chronically underpaid.)
Osvaldo Alonso, Seattle ($68,737)
(Midfield ball vacuum makes more than he could have in native Cuba—but not by much.)
Chris Wondolowski, San Jose ($48,000)
(Sixth-year forward is having career year with team-leading 7 goals.)
Justin Braun, Chivas USA ($67,500)
(Leads team with 7 goals and 3 assists.)
Andy Najar, D.C. United ($58,995)
(17-year-old rookie may have MLS’s biggest upside; leads team with 3 goals.)
Álvaro Saborío, Salt Lake ($128,125)
(Great pickup for the league champs: he leads the team with 8 league goals.)
Michael Stephens, Los Angeles ($42,500)
(Promising rookie has 7 assists.)
Geoff Cameron, Houston ($40,000)
(League-minimum salary for 2009 MLS Best XI player? Cameron clearly looking to play out contract and leave on free transfer.)
Steven Lenhart, Columbus ($42,333)
(Megahustler has 4 goals this season.)
Kevin Hartman, Dallas ($80,000)
(One of league’s best-ever keepers has been solid since winning starting role.)
Omar Cummings, Colorado ($80,250)
(Not quite as good as in 2009, but he still has 5 goals.)
Fredy Montero, Seattle ($180,000)
(23-year-old has entered MVP race with 8 goals and 9 assists.)
Javier Morales, Salt Lake ($252,500)
(Playmaker does a bit of everything for RSL, has 6 goals and 6 assists.)
Zack Schilawski, New England ($42,500)
(Rookie has 5 goals, including a hat-trick.)
Robbie Findley, Salt Lake ($87,316)
(World Cup participant has 5 goals, nearing end of contract.)
Dan Gargan, Toronto ($40,000)
(Unlikely assists leader with 4 for the Reds.)
Brandon McDonald, San Jose ($40,000)
(Steady starter for Frank Yallop’s team.)
Jonathan Bornstein, Chivas USA ($100,000)
(Low salary for a guy who played well in the World Cup and is headed to Mexico’s Tigres in January.)
A.J. DeLaGarza, Los Angeles ($45,100)
(Part-time starter has fit in well with Galaxy.)
Nana Attakora, Toronto ($40,000)
(One of Preki’s regulars in TFC back line.)
What are your thoughts on the latest MLS salary info?
WHAT TO WATCH
This isn’t a complete listing of available games in the U.S., but these are the best live games available this weekend:
FRIDAY
• Bayern Munich-Wolfsburg (Germany), 2:30 p.m. ET, ESPN Deportes
SATURDAY
• Arsenal-Blackpool (England), 10 a.m. ET, ESPN2
• Everton-Wolves (England), 10 a.m. ET, FSC
• Wigan-Chelsea (England), noon ET, FSC
• Hamburg-Schalke (Germany), 12:30 p.m. ET, GolTV
• Toronto-New York (MLS), 1 p.m. ET, MLS Direct Kick
• San Jose-Los Angeles (MLS), 4 p.m. ET, TeleFutura
• Pachuca-Monterrey (Mexico), 8 p.m. ET, TeleFutura
SUNDAY
• Newcastle-Aston Villa (England), 8:30 a.m. ET, FSC Plus
• Fulham-Manchester United (England), 11 a.m. ET, FSC
• PSG-Bordeaux (France), 3 p.m. ET, FSC Plus